Homemade Lobster Roll Recipe

Homemade Lobster Roll Recipe

On hot summer days, coming to New England you will enjoy the special flavor of lobster rolls. This is a famous New England dish that anyone who comes here wants to enjoy. If you are afraid to go out, you can also do it yourself at home. Here is a New England lobster roll recipe that you can refer to to make at home.

lobster roll recipe

Choosing lobster for lobster roll

Before preparing the lobster roll recipe, it is important that you choose the lobster. Choosing fresh lobster is very important to get the best dish. Some ways to choose lobster that you should know.

Choose live lobster

Choosing fresh lobster means that it has not gone through the freezing process. While people have just brought them home, you can always choose to bring them home for processing. First, you want to choose a fresh, delicious lobster, the lobster must be alive and healthy and swimming around in the water. When holding a lobster on the lobster's body, it bends, and it thrashes and kicks.

Homemade Lobster Roll Recipe

Frozen lobster

Frozen lobster, the buyer will have 2 choices. That is to buy cooked lobster meat or you can also buy uncooked meat from the markets. But must choose a safe and hygienic buying address. Buying uncooked frozen lobster is safer because you know its condition. 

Buy lobster at Fishermen's Net

Buying frozen lobster at Fishermen's Net is an option that has been bought by many. Only people living here will not be able to go directly to the market to buy products. That's why you can order lobster by mail at Fishermen's Net. At this address you will buy fresh, frozen lobsters even if you want to let live lobsters overnight. You'll enjoy fresh local lobsters so you can make lobster rolls.

On the market today, there are many places that provide frozen or fresh lobster, but not all of them guarantee the quality. Fishermen's Net promises on-time shipping, careful packaging and food safety. In addition, the price here is not too expensive like other places. Here you just need to order and choose a shipping unit, Fishermen's Net will deliver to your door.

Lobster roll ingredients and recipe

Once you have chosen to buy a delicious fresh lobster, you will need to prepare some more ingredients to make a lobster roll. The more complete the selection, the better the taste will be.


  • 2 lobsters
  • 1 sprig of chopped celery
  • 1/4 cup mayonnaise
  • 1 teaspoon chives
  • 1 lemon
  • 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 4 New England sausage rolls
  • 1/4 teaspoon black pepper
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • Hot dog bun


Recipe Note:

  • Servings: 4 people
  • Prep: 10 mins
  • Cook: 10 mins
  • Total time: 20 mins

Lobster roll recipe

Step 1: Wash the lobster thoroughly, drain the water, and cut the lobster meat into small pieces.

Step 2: Put the celery, mayonnaise, chives, lime juice, lemon zest, kosher salt and ground black pepper in a large bowl and mix well to form a paste. Add some necessary seasoning to taste.

Step 3: Take a saucepan over low heat and bring 2 tablespoons of butter to a boil. In 2 minutes the butter will melt. While waiting for the butter to melt, add the lobster meat. Dip the lobster meat in the mixture from step 2. Melt the remaining butter and bake the sausages for about 2 minutes until golden brown.

Step 4: Finally, add lobster sauce to hot dog bun or eat with vermicelli. So you have finished the lobster roll with many special flavors.

How to treat lobster before cooking?

For live or frozen lobsters, you must know how to handle them before processing. If handled improperly, it can lead to lobster losing its flavor. If you buy live lobster, just put it in the fridge and then wash it. Or with frozen lobster meat but already cooked, just defrost it in the refrigerator. So you can process it immediately without taking too much time.

Besides, with uncooked frozen lobster, it will take longer. Because lobster meat is fresh and delicious, it must be frozen, so it will be difficult to defrost in a short time. You can put it in an airtight bag and let it defrost for up to 2 hours. After defrosting, don't forget to steam it in salted water. The time will depend on the size of the lobster, you can base it between 5 and 7 minutes.

Handling frozen lobster does not take too much effort, everything is very simple. Depending on the size as well as the degree of freezing of the lobster to know the defrosting time.

Discover more recipes

Some tips for the perfect lobster roll

The first tip is to choose the best lobster when you already know the lobster roll recipe. Many people often choose to buy cooked frozen lobster, but they do not choose to buy fresh meat. You can choose a whole cooked lobster or choose a lobster tail which is also very suitable for lobster rolls.

Use melted butter to warm the lobster meat. Before adding the meat to the mayo, use a pan with butter, and heat the meat for about 2 minutes. And especially do not cook for too long so that the lobster meat will be tough. Gently warm the lobster meat in the melted butter like butter poached lobster recipe. Before combining with the mayo, warm the lobster meat in the pan with melted butter for 2-3 minutes. Pay attention not to cook for a long time, otherwise it will be tough and overcooked.

Spoon the lobster into the melted sauce with a slotted spoon. Because although when cooked, the lobster's heart secretes flavor into the butter, but when put in mayo it will melt and not cling to the lobster meat.

Choosing soft and fluffy hot dog bun will make the taste of the lobster roll more delicious. Choosing a New England hot dog sandwich is also very appropriate. However, you should choose carefully to avoid buns that stay too long, dry or go rancid.

If you apply these methods and use the lobster roll recipe mentioned above, you will surely have a very delicious lobster roll.




How to make lobster roll dressing?

The sauce to add flavor to the lobster rolls is not difficult to make. You just need to apply the recipe and some small notes to perfect the sauce.

how to cook lobster roll

The first is to marinate lobster meat with mayonnaise, this is necessary for lobster rolls. However, you should only give mayonnaise at a moderate level, do not overdo them and give too much. Only give a serving size of about 1/4 cup small mayonnaise for 1 about 1 pound lobster.

If you like lobster with a crunchy texture and extra flavor, add a layer of celery skin. Use chopped onions to add in so that the pieces are not too big. You can also consider whether or not to add celery depending on individual preferences.

For the sauce, lemon juice is indispensable. Taking both lemon juice and lemon peel will help keep the sauce from being diluted, making the noodles more delicious. Before squeezing the lemon, peel it off first, add the lemon juice and lemon zest into the mayo mixture. It will also help the seafood become brighter.

Add chives to lobster sauce to add flavor as well as garnish the dish to become more delicious. Do not leave the chives whole, but chop the chives into small pieces. Applying these methods will definitely make a delicious sauce for lobster rolls. 

However, it is not always advisable to use all the ingredients in the instructions. And if there is an ingredient you don't like or can't eat, you can leave it out. Although it will lose a bit of flavor, it must match the taste of the eater to be considered delicious.

Side dishes with lobster roll

Eating lobster roll will be more delicious if there are accompanying dishes. Depending on the preferences of each person, you can eat anything you want. In particular, it has been commented that if the lobster roll is missing the fries, it will lose some of its flavor. That's why french fries are an indispensable side dish. French fries when served need to be a little salty and as crispy as possible. Maybe the french fries sauce with salt and vinegar will be much better. So when eating lobster rolls, you should make yourself a little more fries. This will be a dish only eaten once but the taste will be remembered forever.

Or you can serve lobster roll with some lobster salad or lobster mac and cheese in hot dog bun instead.

New England lobster roll is a famous dish all over the world. Any visitor coming here will find and enjoy this dish. If you don't have the opportunity to come here to enjoy it in person, you can order it yourself at Fishermen's Net. Then apply the lobster roll recipe to make this dish yourself. Above is the information shared about the lobster roll recipe and the address to help you buy the best quality lobster. Hopefully through that you will get the best lobster roll.

Visit our blog for more useful tips related to the lobster. Feel free to contact us via the below contact information if you have any further questions or requests.

  • Website: www.mualobster.com
  • Address: 849 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103.
  • Tel: +1 (207) 772-3565.
Back to blog

Our Best Selling

Here you will find some of our most often purchases as well our specials that we are currently running